EACE Journal — Vol. 16, No. 1
Difficulties, Preconceptions and Misconceptions that Hinder Learning Lean Construction and Ways to Overcome these Obstacles: A Literature Review
Fekadu Melese, Ruth A. Streveler, Mary K. Pilotte and Makarand Hastak
Abstract
Challenges, preconceived notions, and misunderstandings that obstruct the learning of lean construction requires identification and the design of corrective instructional strategies. Therefore, the inquiry arises as to whether the conceptual transformations brought about by the recommended instructional strategies can be assessed. The purposes of this paper are to identify difficulties, preconceptions and misconceptions that hinder learning lean construction, to forward effective instructional interventions to overcome the problems from scholarly literature in engineering education, and to give ways to measure conceptual changes attained by the suggested instructional interventions. Identification of difficulties, preconceptions and misconceptions in learning lean construction are made, and suggestions on effective solutions from scholarly engineering education literature forwarded. Assessment strategies of conceptual change brought about by the suggested instructional interventions are also forwarded. Pertinent literature on teaching lean and difficulties in teaching lean construction are reviewed from lean research. Difficulties, preconceptions, misconceptions, conceptual change, concept inventories and assessment of learning are reviewed from engineering education research. Difficulties, preconceptions, and misconceptions in lean construction are identified from lean research papers, and instructional interventions are forwarded from engineering education research. The idea is to bring in information from engineering education research to solve instructional problems in teaching lean construction. Difficulties, preconceptions and misconceptions that hinder understanding of lean construction concepts are identified from lean scholarly literature. How these problems hinder learning lean construction are pointed out, and effective instructional interventions suggested with ways to assess conceptual changes attained by suggested instructional interventions from scholarly engineering education literature. The best way to assess conceptual change is by using concept inventories but because lean construction is an emerging field internationally, concept inventories are not yet developed for it. Concept inventories are developed for mature fields and few concept inventories are developed internationally in such fields and subjects as physics, biology, chemistry, computer programming, statics, etc. Learning objectives based rubric and assessment sheet are the only available ways to assess conceptual change in lean construction, which has got some limitations. Effective lean learning facilitates lean implementation and practice. Learning lean construction will be more effective and faster if educators can identify problems that hinder learning so that effort is directed towards overcoming the issues. Findings help better understanding of teaching methods to use in case learners have difficulties, preconceptions and misconceptions. Information from this research can be used in future research to develop concept inventories in lean construction, which is the recommended tool to cure misconceptions. Key Words: Difficult concepts, preconceptions, misconceptions, conceptual change, concept inventories, learning lean construction.
Read Full Article (PDF)