EACE Journal — Vol. 16, No. 1
Automated Thickness Design and Sensitivity Analysis for Rigid Pavements (AASHTO and PCA)
Semere Mesfin Gebresilassie, Ashenafi Aregawi Weldemichael and Daniel Hagos Gebre
Abstract
Rigid pavements provide enhanced durability and reduced maintenance costs; however, their design according to AASHTO (1993) and PCA methodologies necessitates intricate manual computations that are susceptible to inaccuracies. This research initiative has resulted in the development of PCAA Pave software using Microsoft Visual Basic 2008 to facilitate the automation of thickness design for both methodologies. Validation against manual computations and the MULTI-PAVE software indicated a remarkable agreement, with thickness discrepancies remaining below 0.4 inches for AASHTO and fatigue as well as erosion damage estimations within ±1-5% for PCA. Sensitivity analysis employing a one-at-a-time method and Monte Carlo simulation (10,000 scenarios executed in Python) effectively quantified the influences of various parameters. In the context of AASHTO, the factors of Reliability (NSI = 0.254, +1.10 in) and Traffic (ESAL) (NSI = 0.210, +0.91 in) were found to be predominant, followed by the Drainage Coefficient (NSI = 0.185, -0.80 in) and the Load Transfer Coefficient (NSI = 0.150, +0.65 in). The influence of material properties was determined to be minimal. Regarding PCA, the Subgrade Modulus (NSI = 0.325, -0.41 in) and the Modulus of Rupture (NSI = 0.310, -0.39 in) were found to significantly dominate the analysis, with the Design Period and Traffic (ADT) displaying only a moderate level of influence. The Monte Carlo simulation confirmed the subgrade modulus as the paramount factor in PCA, exhibiting a sensitivity that is nearly fivefold greater than that of the traffic parameters. The comparative analysis explains fundamental philosophical distinctions: AASHTO is predominantly influenced by traffic and reliability, whereas PCA is primarily controlled by the support offered by subgrade and the inherent material strength. These insights empower engineers to execute method-specific data prioritization, facilitating accurate traffic predictions for AASHTO and careful subgrade characterization for PCA. The validated PCAA Pave software serves as a dependable and time-efficient design tool; however, it is advisable to consider future enhancements in the analysis of reinforcement and joint designs. Keywords: Rigid Pavement, AASHTO 1993, PCA Method, Sensitivity Analysis, Monte Carlo Simulation, PCAA Pave Software
Read Full Article (PDF)