Telegram Facebook

EACE Journal — Vol. 15, No. 1

Application of an Alternative Multi-Criteria Federal Road Projects Selection Using Integrated Analytic Hierarchy Process and Linear Programming Models

Tewodros Abere Ambaw, Abraham Assefa Tsehaye, PhD

Abstract

Abstract The allocation of resources in federal road projects in Ethiopia is critical multi-criteria decision challenge which requires proper analysis, ranking and selection of projects. Unfortunately, the selected projects are also facing delays and cost overruns. The project selection methods commonly used are quantitative in nature and lack to consider intangible factors which can affect the outcome of project appraisals. An integrated Analytic Hierarchy Process and Linear Programming model that considered both quantitative and qualitative factors in choosing capital project is presented. The combined model is applied in Ethiopian Roads Administration projects with Federal Planning and Development Commission and Ministry of Finance as prime stakeholders in project selections. Research surveys were conducted in those organizations and secondary documents were used for in-depth analysis. The results indicated that project characteristics, with 0.5 weight, were ranked higher than other criteria related to the firm characteristic and external factors which had weights of 0.36 and 0.14, respectively. The most important project selection sub-criteria were profit, measure of worth, project risk, financial standing, and resources with the overall weight of 0.15, 0.13, 0.12, 0.10 and 0.09, respectively. Four projects selected out of six had the best use of resources. The integrated model is recommended for future applications due to its ability to capture all potential factors and produce optimal solution and applicability in different situations with refining the selection criteria. Key Words: Analytic Hierarchy Process, Linear Programming, Project Appraisal, Resource Constraint, Optimality

Read Full Article (PDF)