EACE Journal — Vol. 12, No. 2
COMPARATIVE CONSTRUCTION COST ANALYSIS OF SELECTED DESIGN-BID-BUILD (DBB) &DESIGN-BUILD (DB) ROAD PROJECTS IN ETHIOPIA
Muluken Shibru Zeberga, M.Sc, Solomon Sertse Deseta, Ph.D.
Abstract
Design-Bid-Build (DBB) and Design-Build (DB) are two of the most common Project Delivery Systems (PDSs) that have been widely used in the international and local construction industry. In the bidding phase, unlike with DBB, the responsive design-builder offers a lump-sum amount using an incomplete, detailed engineering design. Although the DB-PDS provides better cost certainty, that certainty may come at a higher premium as compared to the DBB. This is because the design-builder allocates a risk factor to compensate for design risk as well as a lack of information to estimate the work quantities. Prior studies have demonstrated that the cost certainty is in favor of DB projects rather than DBB. However, they don’t examine the amount of risk that comes with cost certainty. To fill this gap, this study undertakes a cost comparison between road projects delivered through the DBB and DB-PDS using one of the static construction cost performance metrics (i.e., cost-per-kilometer). The study considers the Ethiopian Road Administration (ERA) as a study context because it has rich experience in both the DBB and DB PDSs as compared to other similar local entities. Accordingly, based on predefined selection criteria and a rigorous case selection process, the study selected seven best-fit cases (i.e., 3 DBB and 4 DB road projects) tendered by the Administration from 2009 to 2017 and classified them into four case groups. A holistic multiple-case study design, primary sources of data, and document analysis were used as a methodology to conduct the comparative analysis. After reviewing and ensuring the similarities between the selected case projects, the identified DB’s bill quantities for selected pay items were multiplied by the corresponding and comparable DBB’s bill item-unit rates. The cost-per-kilometer comparison showed that the DB-PDS costs, on average, 13.7% more than the DBB-PDS. It is also expected from the theoretical justification that, due to the lack of detailed information, the design-builder can include a higher premium for potential risks. As a result, unless the project has a high state of urgency, the DBB-PDS is a better option than the DB-PDS from a static cost and performance perspective alone.
Read Full Article (PDF)